Skip to content
Andrews Dean
← Field Notes
June 10, 20263 minReplacing the spreadsheet

Have you sat in the room your product is used in?

Users don't live in your forms. They live in the moment your product gets used. Design that moment and the forms almost design themselves.

Same meeting, redesigned
Screen share
?

Everyone squints at the same shared cells.

Presentation Mode

Nominee — Team Ops

ApproveRejectDefer14 of 40

One nomination, full screen, one key to decide.

Have you ever sat in the room where your product is actually used?

I almost didn't. And I almost built the wrong thing because of it.

The obvious build

A rewards-and-recognition process I worked on ran on a monthly ritual. Managers fill nominations into an Excel sheet. Then everyone joins a call, someone shares their screen, and the group talks through each one and approves it live.

My first instinct was the obvious one. Build the forms. Clean list, filters, approve buttons. Digitize the data and call it a day.

Then I sat through the ritual one more time, and I realized I was about to solve the wrong problem. The pain was never filling in nominations. The pain was the call. Squinting at a shared spreadsheet. Scrolling to find the row someone was talking about. Nobody quite sure what got decided until a person typed "Yes" into a cell.

Designing the meeting, not the form

So the best feature in the whole tool became a Presentation Mode. Full screen, one nomination at a time, built for exactly that meeting. Big readable type. The scorecard shown as bars instead of cells. Approve, reject or defer with a single key. A running tally. Everyone's screen updating live as decisions land.

I stopped designing the database form and started designing the forty-five minutes where the actual decisions happen.

Here's the line I keep coming back to: users don't live in your forms. They live in the moment your product gets used.

The meeting. The handoff. The two-minute panic before a deadline. Design that moment well and the forms almost design themselves. It's like building a kitchen. You can obsess over the cabinets, but people remember the dinner.

The reframe

Digitize a process and you get a database. Design the ritual and you get something people actually feel.

The real test of whether it worked wasn't the meeting getting shorter, though it did. It was leadership starting to pull up the program's leaderboard in performance reviews, months later, without anyone telling them to. Nobody references a scoreboard they don't trust.

So let me ask you what I forgot to ask myself. Where does your product truly get used, and have you ever sat quietly in that room and watched?

This is the product the essay describes — see R&R App.

product-managementdiscoveryuxdesign

Contact

Let's talk.

If you're building an AI-first product org — or you need someone who can take a vague mandate and return a shipped, adopted product — I'd like to hear about it.

hello@andrewsdean.com · Noida (Delhi NCR), India